The quote is not the level
Updated: Oct 18
Is an investment priced from a broker quote a Level 1, 2 or 3 fair value measurement?

Every year-end, the pricing file has a column headed "Source". Next to the listed shares it says "exchange". Next to the unlisted bonds, the private credit and the over-the-counter derivatives it says "broker", and the hierarchy column beside it says "Level 2". The reasoning is rarely written down, because it feels obvious: a third party gave us the price, so the price must be observable.
That shortcut is wrong more often than it is right. Who supplied the price tells you almost nothing. IFRS 13 classifies a measurement by the inputs behind it, and the same broker can send you a Level 1 price on Monday and a Level 3 price on Friday.
The hierarchy ranks inputs, not sources
IFRS 13 ranks the inputs to a valuation, not the people or the methods that produce it (IFRS 13.72). A measurement is categorised in its entirety at the level of the lowest-level input that is significant to the measurement as a whole (IFRS 13.73).
The IFRS Interpretations Committee applied this to third-party prices in January 2015. Its agenda decision says the level depends on the inputs the third party used to derive the price, not on its pricing method, and that a measurement based on third-party prices can be Level 1 only if it relies solely on unadjusted quoted prices in an active market for an identical instrument that the entity can access at the measurement date.
IFRS 13 lets you use prices from brokers and pricing services, but only once you have determined that they were developed in line with the Standard (IFRS 13.B45). The level is your conclusion, not the broker's, and you cannot reach it about a price whose make-up you do not know.
Four questions that place a broker quote
Is it the price of the identical instrument in an active market you can access? An active market is one where transactions happen often enough, and in enough volume, to give pricing information on an ongoing basis (IFRS 13 Appendix A). If the quote is that price, unadjusted, the measurement is Level 1 (IFRS 13.76–77). For broker-priced assets this is the exception. Most bonds trade over the counter in dealer and brokered markets rather than on an exchange (IFRS 13.B34), and one dealer's quote for a thinly traded bond rarely shows an active market.
Is it binding or indicative? A binding or executable quote is a price at which the dealer will actually trade. An indicative quote is the broker's view of where the price might be. IFRS 13 asks you to weigh the evidence according to the nature of the quote, giving more weight to binding offers (IFRS 13.B47). An indicative quote with nothing behind it is not, on its own, an observable price.
Can you corroborate it with observable market data? Level 2 inputs are observable, directly or indirectly: quoted prices for similar instruments in active markets, quoted prices for identical or similar instruments in markets that are not active, and inputs such as yield curves and credit spreads (IFRS 13.81–82). If recent trades in the same or comparable instruments, or the broker's disclosed inputs, support the price, it is Level 2. If the price rests on the broker's own assumptions about defaults, prepayments or recoveries, and those assumptions are significant, it is Level 3 (IFRS 13.86–87).
Is the market still trading normally? Few recent transactions, quotes that are not based on current information, quotes that vary a lot over time or between market-makers, and wide bid-ask spreads all point to a significant fall in market activity (IFRS 13.B37). You then have to judge whether the quotes reflect orderly transactions or market participants' assumptions, and give less weight to quotes that do not reflect actual transactions (IFRS 13.B44 and B46). An instrument that was Level 2 last year can be Level 3 this year without anything about it changing except the market.
Two further rules close the loop. If you adjust a Level 1 price, for example because a significant event happened after the market closed, the result is no longer Level 1 (IFRS 13.79). And if an observable price needs an adjustment that uses a significant unobservable input, the measurement drops to Level 3 (IFRS 13.75).
Same broker, three answers
Take three holdings in one portfolio at 31 December 2026, all priced by the same broker:
Holding and price evidence | Level | Why |
Euro government bond; executable dealer quotes, traded every day | 1 | Identical instrument, active market, no adjustment |
Listed corporate bond that trades a few times a month; two binding quotes within 0.4% of each other and of last week's trades | 2 | Observable, and corroborated by trades |
Unlisted CLO tranche; one indicative quote from the broker's own default and prepayment model | 3 | Significant unobservable inputs |
The word "broker" appears in every row. It decided none of them.
Put the evidence on the file
A reviewer or auditor will want to see, for each material broker-priced position:
who supplied the price, and whether it is binding, executable or indicative
how many quotes you obtained, how far apart they are and how old they are
what you know about the inputs and method behind each quote
the corroboration: comparable trades, back-testing against later sales, or an independent price check
the level concluded, with the reason, and any transfer between levels since last year
Set your tolerances before you see the prices. If your policy says quotes more than 5% apart must be investigated, quotes of 96.20, 97.00 and 103.40 for the same bond, a spread of 7.4% of the middle quote, are a finding rather than a rounding difference. Wide dispersion is itself a sign that the inputs are not observable.
What changes in the notes
The level drives the disclosure load. For recurring fair value measurements, IFRS 13.93 requires:
the level of each class of assets and liabilities (93(b))
transfers between Level 1 and Level 2, with the reasons, and your policy for when transfers are deemed to occur (93(c) and 95)
for Levels 2 and 3, a description of the valuation techniques and inputs used (93(d))
for Level 3, quantitative information about the significant unobservable inputs (93(d)), a reconciliation of opening to closing balances (93(e)), a description of the valuation process (93(g)) and a narrative of the sensitivity to those inputs (93(h))
One relief is worth knowing. If you use a third-party price without adjusting it and did not develop the unobservable inputs yourself, you need not create the quantitative input table, although you cannot ignore significant inputs that are reasonably available to you (IFRS 13.93(d)). The rest of the Level 3 disclosures still apply, as does the duty to explain significant judgements and sources of estimation uncertainty (IAS 1.122 and 125, moved into IAS 8 by IFRS 18).
What the auditor will ask
Auditors treat a broker or pricing service as an external information source (ISA 500) and, under ISA 540 (Revised), expect management to understand how the price was produced. Level 3 positions often carry high estimation uncertainty and are frequently assessed as a significant risk. Expect questions on the pricing source's method, the dispersion and age of the quotes, and the evidence for the level you chose. Our audit tools follow the same path:
Risk Matrix: score the valuation risk and flag it as significant (ISA 315)
Procedure Builder: design responses such as independent price checks and back-testing (ISA 330)
Disclosure Review: check that the IFRS 13 notes are complete
Work it through, one measurement at a time
Our IFRS 13 Fair Value Levels tool asks exactly these questions. Its broker-quotes step records whether each quote is binding or indicative, tests dispersion and staleness against your own policy limits, asks whether you understand the source's inputs, and shows the level the evidence points to. It then finds the lowest-level significant input, keeps an evidence register, and assembles the IFRS 13.93 disclosure data, including the Level 3 reconciliation, ready for review and sign-off.
It does not value anything: the prices still come from your broker or valuer. It documents and challenges them. It is free with a member account.
Fair value is not only for investments. A loan to a group company at a below-market rate starts at fair value too, and the market rate you choose is an input that sits somewhere in this same hierarchy. The free Intercompany Loans template works out that day-one fair value and the interest that unwinds over the term.
The broker supplies a number. The level is a conclusion about what that number is made of, and only you can reach it.





