Paid on day one, earned later
Updated: Oct 18
How should an entity account for an upfront non-refundable fee when no distinct service is transferred, and when does revenue recognition extend beyond the initial contract term?

Joining fees, activation fees, set-up fees, enrolment fees. The customer pays them on day one, cannot get them back, and the invoice usually describes some work: opening the account, running checks, configuring the system. It is tempting to book the cash as revenue straight away. It is almost as tempting to go the other way and spread it over however long customers tend to stay.
IFRS 15 allows neither shortcut. "Non-refundable" says the customer cannot reclaim the money; it says nothing about whether you have earned it. And how long you spread it over is not a policy choice. It follows from three separate questions, answered in order.
The running example
A hosted payroll provider charges new customers a €300 joining fee and €1,200 a year for the service, billed monthly at €100. The contract is for one year. Customers who renew pay €1,200 a year and never pay the joining fee again. In the week before the service starts, the provider sets up the customer's profile in its own systems.
Question 1: does the fee buy anything?
Activities you must carry out to fulfil a contract are not performance obligations unless they transfer a good or service to the customer (IFRS 15.25). Setting up the customer's profile in your own systems lets you provide the payroll service later; on its own, it gives the customer nothing.
When that is the case, the fee is an advance payment for the future service. You hold it as a contract liability and recognise it as revenue when that service is provided (IFRS 15.B49). Calling it an "activation service" on the invoice does not change this.
If the set-up does transfer something to the customer, for example training the customer's staff or migrating the customer's own data in a form they can use, ask whether that is distinct (IFRS 15.27). If it is, it is a performance obligation and earns part of the price when it is delivered. If it is not, it is combined with the payroll service and recognised with it (IFRS 15.B50).
Either way, "amortising the fee" is only shorthand. Nothing is being amortised. Revenue is recognised as promises are satisfied.
Question 2: does the right to renew without the fee give the customer a material right?
This question decides how long the fee is deferred. IFRS 15.B49 extends the recognition period beyond the initial contract only if the option to renew gives the customer a material right: a benefit they would not get without entering into this contract, and which is more than the discounts other customers of that class receive (IFRS 15.B40).
Compare complete prices, not invoice lines. A new customer pays €1,500 for a first year of payroll; an existing customer renews for €1,200. That €300 gap is the possible right. Whether it is material is a judgement on quantitative and qualitative factors, and the evidence matters more than the contract wording:
Is the fee actually charged? A €300 fee that sales routinely waive for comparable new customers gives little advantage to those who renew. A fee that is always enforced does.
Could the customer get the same service elsewhere without a fee? If competitors charge nothing to join, avoiding your fee is worth less.
Does avoiding the fee influence renewal? If a customer would think twice before leaving because coming back, or switching, means paying again, the right has value.
Two arguments do not work. The first is dilution: a customer who stays five years pays €6,300, so €300 looks small. Using the expected lifetime to dismiss the right, and then recognising the fee over the one-year contract, measures the same customer over two different periods. The second is loyalty: customers who stay because the service is good, or because switching is a nuisance, are not exercising a right you granted. The test question for your file is simple:
What can this customer get on renewal, because of the original contract, that an otherwise comparable new customer cannot?
Question 3: how much belongs in each period?
The answer to Question 2 sets the horizon. The allocation sets the amounts.
No material right. The fee is part of the price of the one-year contract and is recognised over that year as the payroll service is provided. IFRS 15 Illustrative Example 53 reaches this answer for a set-up fee on a one-year processing contract. The horizon is the contractual service period, which is not the billing interval: monthly invoices do not make a one-year contract a one-month one.
A material right, measured directly. The right is a separate performance obligation. You estimate its stand-alone selling price from the discount and the likelihood of exercise (IFRS 15.B42) and allocate the price on a relative basis. If the right covers one renewal year and 80% of customers are expected to renew, the option is worth €300 × 80% = €240. The €1,500 is then split €1,500 × 1,500 ÷ 1,740 = €1,293 to year one and €1,500 × 240 ÷ 1,740 = €207 to the right. The €207 is recognised with the renewal year's service, or when the right lapses. Note that it is not €300: the invoice line and the allocation are different things.
A material right, using the practical alternative. Where the right is to more of the same service on the original terms, IFRS 15.B43 lets you allocate by reference to the services you expect to provide and the consideration you expect to receive (Example 51). Suppose your renewal data, for customers on these terms, supports an expected five years of service. Expected consideration is €300 + €1,200 × 5 = €6,300, or €1,260 for each year of service:
Year | Revenue | Contract liability |
1 (cash €1,500) | €1,260 | €240 |
2 (cash €1,200) | €1,260 | €180 |
3 (cash €1,200) | €1,260 | €120 |
4 (cash €1,200) | €1,260 | €60 |
5 (cash €1,200) | €1,260 | €0 |
Total (cash €6,300) | €6,300 |
That is the €100 billed each month plus €5 released from the contract liability. When the fee is received, debit cash €300 and credit contract liability €300; each month, credit revenue with €105. The renewal payments you expect are inputs to the allocation, not receivables: you have no right to them until the customer renews.
Side by side, the three answers for year one are:
Conclusion | Year 1 revenue | Still deferred |
No material right | €1,500 | €0 |
Material right over one renewal year (B42) | €1,293 | €207 |
Material right over five expected years (B43) | €1,260 | €240 |
The differences look small for one customer. Across a book of thousands, they decide whether deferred revenue on the balance sheet is right.
When the estimates move
Renewals differ from expectations. Example 51 requires the allocation to be updated for actual renewals. That is a change in estimate (IAS 8), accounted for from now on, including any cumulative catch-up the IFRS 15 model produces. It is an error only if the information was already available and you did not use it.
Customers leave but can come back. If a customer who stops paying can return within twelve months without a new fee, the right has not expired just because the account is inactive.
Rights that will never be used. If you expect some rights to go unused, recognise that breakage in proportion to the pattern of rights exercised; otherwise, when the chance of exercise becomes remote (IFRS 15.B46).
Three things the fee does not decide
Your costs. A fee designed to recover set-up costs does not let you defer those costs. They are capitalised only if they meet IFRS 15.95, or another Standard. In March 2020 the IFRS Interpretations Committee confirmed that training costs within IAS 38 are expensed even when the customer is charged for them.
Financing. Deferring the fee for more than a year raises the question of a significant financing component (IFRS 15.60–65). The answer is often no, for example because the customer decides when to use the prepaid service (IFRS 15.62(a)), but it must be considered and documented separately.
Your disclosures. "Upfront fees are amortised over five years" explains nothing. Explain the judgement: why the fee buys no separate service, why a material right exists, how it was allocated and what supports the period, together with the movements in contract liabilities (IFRS 15.116–118, 119 and 123–126).
Work it through with our tools
The allocation is where most of the work sits. Our Bundled Revenue template takes one contract through the five steps in Excel: enter the payroll year and the renewal right as separate promises, give the right its estimated stand-alone selling price, and the workbook allocates the price, schedules the revenue month by month, and gives you the contract liability, the journal and the disclosure figures.
If you are still learning the five steps, the free Promises, Promises trainer walks through IFRS 15 contract by contract. Whether a renewal right is material is a judgement call, and The Tipping Point helps you weigh it and write it up. Before the accounts go out, Disclosure Review checks that the IFRS 15 notes are complete. Material rights also arise outside joining fees; our earlier post on accounting for customer options covers them.
Three questions, three separate conclusions: whether the fee buys anything, whether renewal carries a material right, and how much belongs in each period. A defensible policy needs all three, and the invoice wording settles none of them.



