Forever is not a lease term
Updated: Oct 18
How should an entity account for a land lease with an upfront premium and indefinite renewals?

A government grants a company the use of a plot of land. The company pays a €5,000,000 premium up front and a ground rent of €10,000 a year in arrears, revised to market from time to time. The lease renews indefinitely at no extra cost, and legal title never passes.
The usual write-up goes straight to the interesting question, "is the lease term infinite?", and answers it by asking whether renewal is reasonably certain. Renewal plainly is, so the term is forever, the right-of-use asset is never depreciated and the job is done. That order of analysis is wrong, and it changes the answer. IFRS 16 makes you first work out how long the contract is enforceable, and only then ask what the lessee is reasonably certain to do within that period. For a five-year office lease the two steps collapse into one. For a lease that renews for ever, the first step is most of the analysis.
Is it a lease at all?
A contract contains a lease if it conveys the right to control the use of an identified asset for a period of time in exchange for consideration (IFRS 16.9). Before applying that test, rule out two scope exclusions that do come up with government land: service concession arrangements within IFRIC 12 (IFRS 16.3(c)) and rights to explore for or use minerals and similar resources (IFRS 16.3(a)). Neither usually applies to a plain long leasehold, but say so in the file rather than leave it unsaid.
The objection you will meet is that a right that never ends is not a right "for a period of time", so this is a purchase of land. The IASB considered excluding long-term leases of land from IFRS 16 and decided not to (IFRS 16.BC78): if the contract does not transfer control of the land itself but gives the lessee the right to control its use, it is a lease. Two points on the facts:
Title is evidence, not the test. IFRS 16 has no title test for lessees. That title stays with the state supports the view that control of the land itself was never transferred.
There is no "bargain purchase" switch for lessees. That idea belongs to lessor classification. For a lessee, a purchase option matters only for the liability (IFRS 16.27(d)) and the depreciation period (IFRS 16.32).
Where the right is perpetual by law rather than by successive renewals, Poland's perpetual usufruct being the best-known case, practice is not uniform. If your jurisdiction has a settled local answer, follow it and say so. If it does not, disclose the judgement.
Start with the enforceable period
IFRS 16.B34 sets the outer limit. A lease is no longer enforceable when the lessee and the lessor each have the right to terminate it without the other's permission and with no more than an insignificant penalty. The IFRS Interpretations Committee applied this to leases that renew indefinitely unless either party terminates, in its November 2019 agenda decision on lease term and the useful life of leasehold improvements. Three points from it decide this case:
"Penalty" is economic, not just contractual. You look at the broader economics, not only termination payments. A lessee that has paid a €5,000,000 premium and built on the site faces a very large penalty if it walks away, so the contract stays enforceable well past any nominal renewal date.
Both parties must be able to walk away cheaply. If only one can, the contract is still enforceable. The government's right to take the land back does not shorten the period on its own.
Only then comes reasonable certainty. Once you know how far enforceability runs, you apply IFRS 16.19 and B37–B40 to decide how much of that period the lessee is reasonably certain to use.
The agenda decision also points to IFRS 16.BC156: the lease term should reflect the entity's reasonable expectation of the period during which it will use the asset. No entity reasonably expects to use a site for ever. It expects to use it for a long, estimable period. So the lease term is long but finite, set by expected use within the enforceable period, and the infinite-term problem largely disappears.
Setting the term
The lease term is the non-cancellable period plus any periods the lessee is reasonably certain to extend into, or not to terminate out of (IFRS 16.18–19). Here the incentives all point one way: renewal costs nothing, the premium is sunk and any buildings cannot be taken away. Reasonable certainty is easy. The hard part is the horizon. In practice entities land on the stated renewal cycle, often 99 years, or on the expected economic life of their use of the site. Choose the one the facts support, and write down why.
The numbers
The premium has already been paid, so it goes straight into the right-of-use asset at the amount paid (IFRS 16.24(b)). It is not part of the lease liability, which is the present value of the payments still to be made (IFRS 16.26–27). With an incremental borrowing rate of 7%:
Perpetuity | 99-year term | |
Lease liability: ground rent at 7% (IFRS 16.26) | €142,857 | €142,681 |
Premium paid before commencement (IFRS 16.24(b)) | €5,000,000 | €5,000,000 |
Right-of-use asset | €5,142,857 | €5,142,681 |
At 7%, assuming a perpetuity rather than 99 years changes the liability by €176. That is a feature of the discount rate, not a general truth. A perpetuity is worth rent ÷ rate, which rises steeply as the rate falls:
Discount rate | Perpetuity less 99 years | % of perpetuity |
7% | €176 | 0.1% |
5% | €1,597 | 0.8% |
3% | €17,865 | 5.4% |
2% | €70,397 | 14.1% |
1% | €373,408 | 37.3% |
At 7% the horizon hardly matters. At 2% it does. Recalculate rather than assume, especially for an entity with a strong credit standing or in a low-rate currency.
The liability also barely moves. Interest in year one is €142,681 × 7% = €9,988 against rent of €10,000, so the liability falls by just €12. Over a long horizon the ground rent is almost all interest. That is correct, but it surprises readers who expect a lease liability to run down, so explain it in the notes.
Depreciation
Check one thing first. If the land is held to earn rentals or for capital appreciation and you use the fair value model in IAS 40, the right-of-use asset is investment property and is carried at fair value too (IFRS 16.34). There is nothing to depreciate.
Otherwise, the right-of-use asset is depreciated from commencement to the earlier of the end of its useful life and the end of the lease term (IFRS 16.31–32). Land itself is not depreciated because it has an unlimited useful life (IAS 16.58), but the asset here is not land. It is a right to use land for a period. On a 99-year term, straight-line depreciation of €5,142,681 is €51,946 a year. This is the mainstream position and the one an auditor will expect.
Not depreciating is defensible only if you have concluded that the lease term is indefinite. Once B34 and BC156 lead you to a long but finite term, that position falls away: the term and the depreciation period have to agree. If you do conclude the asset is not depreciated, be aware that it gets no mandatory annual impairment test. IAS 36.10 requires that only for goodwill and certain intangible assets; a right-of-use asset is tested only when there is an indicator of impairment (IAS 36.9 and IFRS 16.33).
Ground rent reviews
The instinct is "the rent is variable, so expense it". IFRS 16 draws the line elsewhere: between payments that depend on an index or a rate, which go into the liability, and other variable payments, which do not (IFRS 16.27(b) and 38(b)). A rent that is revised to market is one of IFRS 16.28's own examples of the first kind.
Include the ground rent in the liability at the rent in force at commencement.
Remeasure the liability when a review actually changes the cash flows, and not before (IFRS 16.42(b)).
Use the original discount rate for that remeasurement (IFRS 16.43), and adjust the right-of-use asset (IFRS 16.39).
A rent review under the existing terms is not a modification. The modification rules (IFRS 16.44–46) apply only if the parties change something the contract did not already provide for, such as adding or surrendering part of the site.
When to reassess the term
IFRS 16.20 requires a reassessment only on a significant event or change in circumstances that is within the lessee's control and affects the assessment. IFRS 16.B41 gives examples: significant improvements not expected at commencement, significant customisation of the asset, or a sublease beyond the current term. A change in government land policy is not within the lessee's control, so it does not trigger a reassessment under 16.20. It may well be an impairment indicator under IAS 36, though.
Separately, IFRS 16.21 revises the term whenever the non-cancellable period changes, with no control condition. In either case the liability is remeasured at a revised discount rate (IFRS 16.40(a)), unlike the unchanged rate used for rent reviews.
Is the low rent a government grant?
The ground rent is far below what a commercial landlord would charge. IFRS 16 does not adjust for that: the liability is measured using the contractual payments. The only place IFRS 16 adjusts off-market terms is sale and leaseback (IFRS 16.101), and that does not carry over to an ordinary lease.
IAS 20 is where the question really sits, and the case for a grant is not weak. IAS 20.10A treats the benefit of a below-market government loan as a grant, and IAS 20.23 deals with grants of non-monetary assets such as land. But a grant also needs assistance in return for compliance with conditions relating to the entity's operating activities, with a value that can reasonably be placed on it (IAS 20.3), and recognition waits until there is reasonable assurance of compliance and receipt (IAS 20.7). So the test is not "is the rent below market?" but:
Is there an identifiable grant, with conditions, that can be measured reliably?
Where low ground rent is simply how the state disposes of land, usually not. Where the site comes through an incentive scheme, for example an enterprise zone or a job-creation condition, usually yes, and the benefit is measured and recognised. Public-sector adaptations of IFRS 16 that gross up leases at nil or nominal consideration do not bind a company applying IFRS Accounting Standards, and a €5,000,000 premium is not nominal consideration anyway.
What to disclose
The judgements and estimates. The enforceable period, the lease term and the grant conclusion are judgements (IAS 1.122); the discount rate and the horizon may be sources of estimation uncertainty (IAS 1.125). From 2027, IFRS 18 moves these requirements into IAS 8.
The amounts. Depreciation by class, interest, total cash outflow, additions and carrying amount by class, in a table (IFRS 16.53–54), and where the right-of-use asset is presented (IFRS 16.47).
The maturity analysis. IFRS 16.58 applies IFRS 7.39 and B11. For a lease this long, nearly all the undiscounted cash flow sits in "more than five years", which tells the reader little, so add further time bands.
The rest of the story. Exposure to rent reviews and the renewal options (IFRS 16.59 and B48–B50).
What the Standards leave open
IFRS 16 has no concept of an indefinite lease term and no method for setting a long one: two entities with identical facts can choose 50 and 150 years and both comply. A right-of-use asset that is not depreciated has no mandatory annual impairment test. And the line between a low price and a government grant turns on a judgement under IAS 20.3 that is hard to test when the state is the only possible counterparty. Reach a position on each, evidence it against B34, BC156 and IAS 20.3, and disclose it.
Work it through with our tools
Our IFRS 16 Lease Calculator handles this kind of lease. It takes an indefinite or rolling lease through its enforceable period, puts the premium into the right-of-use asset as a payment made at commencement, treats a market-review rent as a payment to remeasure when it resets, and runs reassessments at a revised rate. It then produces the schedules, journals and IFRS 16 disclosure amounts, with a judgement log for the lease term. It is free with a member account.
The Tipping Point: weigh the lease term judgement, factor by factor, and write it up.
Government Grants template: if you conclude there is a grant, schedule the grant income over the life of the asset.
CGU Impairment template: test the site, or the unit it belongs to, when a change in land policy or the business gives an indicator of impairment.
Lease Calculator template: an Excel register for the rest of your leases, with terms of up to 25 years.
Disclosure Review: check that the lease and judgement notes are complete.
IFRS 16 in the Learning Hub: the lease term, remeasurement and modifications, from foundation to advanced level.
More Unaddressed! questions on leases: Sublease that ends earlier than head lease and Guarantees of lease payments.
A lease that renews for ever is still a lease, and its term is still finite. What sets the term is how long the contract is enforceable and how long you expect to use the land, not how long the legal right could, in theory, run.




