top of page

One eighth of a business jet

Sep 25
5 min read

Updated: Oct 18

How should an entity account for a fractional interest in a business jet?

Fractional aircraft ownership: genuine title and residual value risk points to IAS 16; a pooled fleet with substitution rights points to a service contract

A fractional programme sells two things at once. The first is a share of a specific aircraft, for example one eighth of a light jet, registered in the buyer's name. The second is a promise of flying hours, typically about 100 a year for an eighth, on whichever aircraft in the manager's fleet is available. The deal is usually documented in four contracts:

  • Purchase agreement: the buyer acquires an undivided interest in a named airframe.

  • Management agreement: the manager crews, insures, hangars, maintains and dispatches the aircraft for a monthly fee, plus an hourly fee for each hour flown.

  • Dry-lease exchange: every owner's share goes into a pool, so the manager can send whichever aircraft is nearest and each owner can fly on the others' aircraft.

  • Exit: at the end of the term, often five years, the manager buys the share back, usually at market value less a remarketing fee.

No IFRS deals with this package as a whole. The way through is to separate what the buyer owns from what it is buying as a service, and the purchase and exit terms decide where that line falls.


When the buyer owns the share: property, plant and equipment

If the buyer holds registered title to an undivided share of a named airframe and bears its residual value risk, because the exit price follows the market, it controls an asset. It can sell or pledge the share, usually subject to the manager's consent or right of first refusal, and it gains or loses as the value of the aircraft moves. That share is property, plant and equipment under IAS 16.


Placing the share in the pool does not change this. IAS 16.6 covers items held for use in supplying services, for rental to others or for administrative purposes, and a share made available to the programme still fits that definition.


The flying is a service, not a lease

The right to fly is a different matter. A lease under IFRS 16 needs an identified asset, and a fractional programme fails that test for two separate reasons:

  • Substitution: the manager can, and does, send a different aircraft, and it benefits from doing so because it positions the fleet efficiently. A substantive substitution right means there is no identified asset (IFRS 16.B14).

  • Capacity: 100 hours of an aircraft that flies about 800 a year is a portion of its capacity that is not physically distinct and is far from substantially all of it, so it is not an identified asset either (IFRS 16.B20).

So even an owner never controls the use of a particular aircraft when it flies, and the monthly and hourly fees are the cost of a service, expensed as the service is received.


Some programmes sell no share in a named airframe at all: a share in a fleet company, a "fractional lease" or a block of hours. With no asset to own and no identified asset to lease, the whole arrangement is a service. An upfront payment is a prepayment, expensed as the hours are used or over the term.


Not a joint arrangement

Several owners holding undivided interests in one aircraft can look like a joint operation, but IFRS 11 needs joint control: decisions about the relevant activities must require the unanimous consent of the parties sharing control (IFRS 11.7). Here the owners have handed dispatch, crewing and maintenance to the manager and have no say over each other's flying. There is no joint control, so IFRS 11 does not apply and each owner accounts for its own share under IAS 16.


Measuring the share

  • Cost: the purchase price plus directly attributable costs such as legal and registration fees (IAS 16.16). Management fees are not part of it.

  • Useful life: the period the buyer expects to hold the share, normally the programme term, not the physical life of the aircraft (IAS 16.57).

  • Residual value: what the buyer would receive today for a share of that age and condition at the end of the term, less the remarketing fee (IAS 16.6), reviewed at least at each year end (IAS 16.51).

  • Depreciation: straight-line usually reflects how the benefit is used, because the hours allowance is the same each year (IAS 16.60). Separate components for engines or airframe (IAS 16.43) seldom matter when the whole share is held for a fixed term, maintained by the manager and sold back at market value; parts with the same life and method can be grouped (IAS 16.45).

  • Fees: the monthly management fee and the hourly fee are operating costs, expensed as incurred.


A worked example

On 1 January, Company A buys a one-eighth share in a light jet for €1,200,000 under a five-year programme with a 100-hour annual allowance. A five-year-old share would sell back today for €440,000, less a €40,000 remarketing fee, so the residual value is €400,000. The management fee is €15,000 a month and the hourly fee is €2,500. In January, Company A flies 10 hours.

  • Purchase: Dr Property, plant and equipment €1,200,000; Cr Cash €1,200,000

  • Management fee for January: Dr Aircraft operating costs €15,000; Cr Cash or payables €15,000

  • Hourly fees (10 hours at €2,500): Dr Aircraft operating costs €25,000; Cr Cash or payables €25,000

  • Depreciation for January: (€1,200,000 − €400,000) ÷ 5 years ÷ 12 = €13,333. Dr Depreciation €13,333; Cr Accumulated depreciation €13,333


If Company A flies its full allowance, a year of the jet costs:


Annual cost (100 hours)

€

Depreciation

160,000

Management fees (12 × €15,000)

180,000

Hourly fees (100 × €2,500)

250,000

Total, or about €5,900 an hour flown

590,000


At the end of year 5 the share is carried at €400,000. If the manager buys it back for €370,000 after its fee, Company A recognises a €30,000 loss on disposal in profit or loss (IAS 16.68 and 16.71).


Read the exit terms

  • Fixed buy-back price: if the manager must buy the share back at a fixed price, the residual value risk stays with the manager and the buyer does not control an asset it can gain or lose on. Mirroring the seller's analysis in IFRS 15.B64–B76, the buyer has a receivable for the buy-back price and has prepaid for the flying in between. If the buy-back price is at least what the buyer paid, it has in substance lent the manager money.

  • Restrictions on sale: a right of first refusal or a consent requirement in the manager's favour does not, on its own, take control of the share away from the buyer.

  • Falling values: used-jet prices can move quickly, and so can a manager's finances. Either is an impairment indicator (IAS 36.12), and the recoverable amount of a share is usually its fair value less costs of disposal.


What the accounts should say

  • The share within property, plant and equipment, with the depreciation method, useful life and the basis of the residual value (IAS 16.73)

  • The judgement that the share is an asset the entity controls, while the flying is a service and not a lease (IAS 1.122)

  • Any restrictions on the share, such as the manager's lien or right of first refusal (IAS 16.74(a))


The brochure calls it ownership, and IFRS asks two narrower questions. Does the buyer hold a share of a named aircraft whose value it bears? If so, there is an asset. Does the buyer control any particular aircraft when it flies? Almost never, which is why the flying is a service.

bottom of page