The discount that was already paid for
Updated: Oct 18
How should an entity account for the exercise of a customer option under IFRS 15?

A customer buys a laptop and leaves with a voucher for 40% off their next purchase. Three months later they come back, buy a monitor and pay 40% less. On the till, the monitor is a €600 sale. Under IFRS 15 it can be a €794 sale, because part of what the customer paid for the laptop was really a payment for the discount on the monitor.
Whether that happens depends on one assessment made at the first sale, not at the second. If the voucher was a material right, the exercise is the second half of a transaction you have already started accounting for. If it was not, the monitor is simply a new sale.
First decide what the voucher was
An option to buy more goods or services is a separate performance obligation only if it gives the customer a material right: something they would not receive without entering into the contract, such as a discount that is more than the discounts normally given to that class of customer in that market (IFRS 15.B40).
An option to buy at the stand-alone selling price is not a material right, even if only existing customers are offered it. It is a marketing offer, and you account for the later purchase if and when it happens (IFRS 15.B41). What matters is the incremental benefit, not the fact that the offer came with the contract.
If it is a material right, part of the first sale is deferred
The voucher becomes a performance obligation, and the first sale's price is split between the laptop and the voucher by relative stand-alone selling price. A voucher rarely has an observable price, so you estimate one: the discount the customer would get on exercise, less any discount they could get anyway, weighted by the likelihood they will use it (IFRS 15.B42). IFRS 15 Illustrative Example 49 works through exactly this.
Take a laptop sold for €1,000, its stand-alone selling price. The voucher gives 40% off the next purchase; the retailer offers every customer 10% off in its seasonal promotions, so the incremental discount is 30%. The retailer expects the next purchase to be about €1,000 and 80% of vouchers to be used:
Voucher's stand-alone selling price: €1,000 × 30% × 80% = €240
Allocated to the laptop: €1,000 × 1,000 ÷ 1,240 = €806.45
Allocated to the voucher: €1,000 × 240 ÷ 1,240 = €193.55
Account | Debit | Credit |
Cash | €1,000.00 | |
Revenue: Product X | €806.45 | |
Contract liability: voucher | €193.55 |
The €193.55 is not revenue yet. The retailer has promised a future discount and has not delivered it.
When the customer uses it
The customer buys a monitor with a list price of €1,000 and pays €600. The deferred amount is released alongside the new cash, as the monitor is delivered:
Account | Debit | Credit |
Cash | €600.00 | |
Contract liability: voucher | €193.55 | |
Revenue: Product Y | €793.55 |
Revenue across both sales is €806.45 + €793.55 = €1,600, which is exactly the cash received. Nothing is created or lost; the voucher simply moves revenue from the first sale to the second.
The IFRS 15 Transition Resource Group discussed the mechanics in March 2015. Most members thought it reasonable to treat the exercise as a continuation of the original contract: the new consideration is added to the transaction price and allocated to the goods now delivered, as above. Treating the exercise as a contract modification was also seen as acceptable. For a simple voucher like this one, both give the same answer, because the monitor is distinct and gets the €193.55 plus the €600 either way. Where they could differ, choose one approach and apply it consistently.
Two mistakes to avoid
Counting the second sale in the first contract. "Most customers use the voucher, so include the €600 in the transaction price now." You have no right to the €600 until the customer chooses to buy. Consideration that depends only on a future exercise is not in the original transaction price; likelihood of exercise goes into the voucher's estimated price, not into the cash you expect.
Leaving the liability on the balance sheet for ever. If the voucher expires unused, the €193.55 has to come out. Where you expect some vouchers to go unused and the amount is not highly likely to reverse, you recognise that breakage in proportion to the vouchers that are redeemed; otherwise, when the chance of redemption becomes remote (IFRS 15.B44–B47).
The same logic, other shapes
Loyalty points work the same way, earned across many sales and redeemed in many small pieces (Illustrative Example 52). Renewal options do too, and for renewals of the same service on the original terms IFRS 15.B43 offers a practical alternative to estimating the option's price directly. A joining fee that is never charged again on renewal is the most common case; our post Paid on day one, earned later works through it.
In one table
Material right | No material right | |
Separate performance obligation? | Yes | No |
Price allocated to the option at the first sale? | Yes, held as a contract liability | No |
Future exercise price in the first contract's price? | No | No |
On exercise | Release the liability with the new consideration as the goods are delivered | A new sale at the price paid |
If it is never used | Breakage (IFRS 15.B46) | Nothing to release |
Work it through with our tools
Our Bundled Revenue template handles the allocation for you. Enter the product and the voucher as separate promises, give the voucher its estimated stand-alone selling price, and the workbook splits the price, schedules the revenue, and gives you the contract liability, the journal and the IFRS 15 disclosure figures.
To practise the five steps first, try Promises, Promises, our IFRS 15 trainer. Whether an option is a material right is a judgement you will need to explain; The Tipping Point helps you weigh it and write it up, and Disclosure Review checks that the revenue notes cover it.
The exercise is rarely the hard part. The hard part is deciding, at the first sale, whether the customer bought a right as well as a product. Once that is settled, the exercise follows.



