Omnibus I traded comparability for relief
Updated: 3 days ago
The EU has cut the number of companies that must report under the CSRD and the number of datapoints they must report. Was the relief for preparers worth what users of the information have lost?

When it was adopted in 2022, the CSRD promised Europe comparable, assured sustainability information from every large company in the Union and from listed smaller ones, on one set of standards. In 2026 the EU took most of that promise back. Omnibus I, Directive (EU) 2026/470, published on 26 February 2026 and in force since 18 March, limits mandatory reporting to companies with more than 1,000 employees and more than €450m of net turnover. The simplified ESRS, Delegated Regulation (EU) 2026/1563, follow for financial years from 1 January 2027.
Much of the relief was deserved. The first ESRS asked too much, and some of what they asked was unreadable. But a reporting regime exists for its users, and the honest description of what happened is this: Europe bought relief for preparers and paid for it in comparability. We think it overpaid.
What was given up
Start with coverage. When the Commission proposed the Omnibus in February 2025, with a 1,000-employee test, it estimated that the number of companies required to report "would be reduced by about 80%" (COM(2025) 81). The law as adopted adds a €450m turnover test on top, so the final cut is deeper still. Listed SMEs are out entirely.
Then the content. The Commission's explanatory memorandum to the simplified ESRS records that EFRAG's draft, delivered on 2 December 2025, cut mandatory datapoints by 61%. The Commission made targeted changes and adopted the final standards on 3 July 2026. The power to adopt sector-specific standards, the part of the regime most likely to make an oil major comparable with an oil major, has been deleted. The empowerment to move to reasonable assurance is gone; assurance stays limited, and even the limited assurance standards have slipped to 1 July 2027.
Feature | Before Omnibus I | After Omnibus I |
|---|---|---|
Who reports | Large or listed | >1,000 staff, >€450m |
Listed SMEs | In scope | Out |
Sector standards | Due June 2026 | Deleted |
Assurance | Path to reasonable | Limited only |
Datapoints, draft | Baseline | −61% |
Finally, optionality. For 2026 financial years a reporter may stay on the 2023 ESRS, use them with selected reliefs from the new set, or adopt the simplified ESRS early, and must say which. The Commission's own recital explains that disclosure as necessary "to ensure transparency and comparability", which is a fair measure of the problem it creates. Member states may release smaller first-wave companies from reporting for 2025 and 2026. Financial holding companies whose subsidiaries operate independently may choose not to report at group level. And everyone below the thresholds may report voluntarily, under the voluntary standard of Delegated Regulation (EU) 2026/1560, or not at all.
The case for the relief
The other side has a serious argument, and the Directive makes it plainly. Its recitals call the largest companies "the most consequential" for environmental, social and governance impacts and "the most able to absorb the costs" of reporting. Concentrating the obligation on them is proportionality, not retreat. EFRAG's cost-benefit analysis, as summarised by the Commission, puts reporting cost savings at 34% of baseline on average over five years, and around €4.7bn over 2027 to 2031 once value-chain effects are counted, with little effect, it says, on what users pay or gain. Those estimates were made on EFRAG's draft, not the final act.
The value-chain cap is a genuine improvement. Smaller suppliers were drowning in questionnaires from customers who were themselves trying to satisfy their assurers. Companies with up to 1,000 employees may now refuse requests that go beyond the voluntary standard, and reporters that respect the cap are deemed to comply. And the simplified ESRS move closer to the ISSB's standards, which matters for groups that report in more than one jurisdiction.
Why it is not enough
We accept most of that, and still think the trade was a bad one.
Comparability is a property of a population, not of a single report. EFRAG can be right that each remaining report is nearly as useful as before, and the system can still be much less useful, because users compare. A bank pricing transition risk across its loan book, or an investor ranking a sector, needs the same data from the whole set. Cut the set by four-fifths or more and let the remainder choose between three routes through two sets of standards for 2026, and the per-report loss looks small while the comparison collapses. The Directive itself concedes the point for financial institutions, whose own disclosure rules depend on this data: it notes that keeping coherence with companies outside the new scope "might require action".
Voluntary reporting does not repair this. It produces self-selected data, and the companies most likely to volunteer are those with good news. The voluntary standard is sensibly designed, but a standard nobody has to use cannot underwrite a comparison.
The deletion of sector standards hurts most. Proportionality would have argued for fewer datapoints and sector standards that made the remaining ones comparable. Europe chose fewer datapoints and no sector standards. And the Directive still requires the ESRS to produce information that is "comparable" (Accounting Directive, Article 29b(2), as amended). It has removed most of the means.
There is also a squeezed middle. A company with 1,200 employees and €300m of turnover is out of scope, so it has no reporting obligation, but it is above the 1,000-employee line, so it has no protection under the value-chain cap. Its customers can still ask for anything.
What it means in Ireland
Ireland transposed the CSRD through the European Union (Corporate Sustainability Reporting) Regulations 2024 (S.I. No. 336 of 2024). It has not yet transposed Omnibus I, and the deadline is 19 March 2027. Until it does, the Irish rules still reflect the original scope. Irish first-wave companies below the new thresholds should watch whether the transposing regulations take up the option to release them from reporting for 2026; until then, they should plan on the law as it stands. Irish first-wave reporters that stay in scope should decide now which ESRS version their 2026 statement will use, and say so clearly. And Irish companies that fall out of scope should expect the questionnaires to continue: the value-chain cap covers only requests made for CSRD reporting, not a lender's own risk management, and their banks' reporting duties have not shrunk.
The Directive asks the Commission to report by 30 April 2031 on whether the scope should be extended. That review should start from what users lost, not only from what preparers saved.
Have your say
Omnibus Watch: the timeline of Omnibus I and the simplified ESRS, and who is in scope now.
Carbon Copy: our sustainability section, read the way an auditor reads it.
Suggest a question: think we have this wrong? Tell us.
Relief was needed, and some of it was well designed. But a disclosure regime that nobody can compare across is a compliance exercise, not an information system. Omnibus I made reporting cheaper. It has not yet shown that it left reporting useful.





