top of page

The subtotal without a name

Oct 19
6 min read
IFRS 18 defines an EBITDA-like subtotal in everything but its name. It should have taken the name as well.

Working-paper illustration: one set of accounts for a fictional group gives three figures that could be called EBITDA. Operating profit of €42.0m plus depreciation and amortisation of €31.0m and IAS 36 impairments of €5.0m gives the IFRS 18.118(b) subtotal of €78.0m. Adding a €6.0m share of joint venture profit gives €84.0m, and adding back €4.0m of restructuring costs gives €82.0m.

From 1 January 2027, IFRS 18 gives the statement of profit or loss a defined operating profit and a defined profit before financing and income taxes (IFRS 18.69). It also brings management's own performance measures into the audited notes, with a reconciliation, a tax effect for each adjustment and a warning that they may not be comparable with anyone else's (IFRS 18.122–123).


EBITDA is among the most quoted of those measures. The IASB looked at it closely, wrote down a calculation for it, and then declined to call that calculation EBITDA. That was a mistake, and the Board can still correct it.


What the Board did

IFRS 18.118 lists six subtotals that are not management-defined performance measures. One of them is "operating profit or loss before depreciation, amortisation and impairments within the scope of IAS 36" (IFRS 18.118(b)). Publish exactly that subtotal and the disclosure regime for management-defined performance measures does not apply. Publish anything else under an EBITDA label in public communications and it does, including a reconciliation to the most directly comparable listed subtotal (IFRS 18.123(c)).


The Basis for Conclusions is candid about the purpose. The Board considered defining EBITDA (BC363). It concluded that the listed subtotal "provides similar information to many of the EBITDA measures currently provided", and that because the measure is well defined, the cost of the extra disclosures would exceed their benefit (BC364). It then decided not to describe the subtotal as EBITDA (BC365), while accepting that an entity with no investing income may label it EBITDA if the label is accurate (BC366).


The history is telling. In November 2018 the Board tentatively decided not to require EBITDA but asked the staff for a description of it that could be exempted. In December 2018 the staff recommended describing EBITDA as operating profit before depreciation and amortisation (Agenda Paper 21B). The Board tentatively decided to exempt the subtotal without the name, by ten votes to four (IASB Update, December 2018). The final standard added IAS 36 impairments. The name never came back.


The case for leaving it unnamed

The Board's reasons deserve a fair hearing, because they are not weak.


First, there is no agreed concept behind EBITDA. The Basis says that "no consensus has been reached on what EBITDA represents" beyond being a starting point for analysis (BC363). Critics add that it is neither cash flow nor profit, and that defining it would bless a measure that ignores the cost of the assets that earn it.


Second, the acronym would mislead. Operating profit under IFRS 18 is not earnings before interest and tax: it excludes income from the investing category, such as the share of profit of associates and joint ventures (IFRS 18.53(a)). Calling the subtotal EBITDA would suggest that it adds back only interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation, when it does more than that (BC365). The Board took the same line on EBIT, declining to label the required profit before financing and income taxes subtotal "EBIT" because the description would rarely be faithful (BC149).


Third, EBITDA is not universal: it is not used in some industries, such as banking and insurance (BC363).


Why those reasons do not hold

Take the concept first. The Board needed no agreed concept to define the subtotal in IFRS 18.118(b); it defined it because it was useful and cheap to exempt. Gross profit is on the same list (IFRS 18.118(a)), and banks do not use that either. The list is permissive. Nobody is forced to report anything on it.


Nor does a definition bless anything that IFRS 18 has not already privileged by exempting it. What the standard withholds is the one thing that would make the calculation comparable in practice: the word users search for. Leaving the label open will not stop companies calling things EBITDA. It only ensures the word means whatever each company says it means.


The acronym point is the strongest, and it proves less than it seems. The IASB staff's own 2018 review of 85 non-financial IFRS reporters found 28 that used the bare label "EBITDA". Only two of them calculated it as operating profit before depreciation, amortisation and impairment, the calculation IFRS 18.118(b) now exempts; 16 used some other definition. Among the 72 that used an EBITDA-type measure, 18 included their share of associates and joint ventures and 22 excluded it (Agenda Paper 21B, December 2018, Appendix A). The acronym is a brand, not a formula. The real choice is between one defined mismatch, explained once in a standard, and many undefined ones, each explained in a different note. BC366, which allows the label where accurate, makes things worse: two compliant reports can use the same word for different calculations, and accuracy is argued case by case.


Users and regulators asked for a definition. A 2016 CFA Institute survey cited by the staff found that 55.1% of 405 respondents expected standard-setters to define key subtotals, including EBITDA. ESMA said in April 2018 that guidance from the IASB "on the definitions of some subtotals (such as operating profits and EBITDA)" would be desirable to reduce diversity (ESMA32-63-424, paragraph 16). And a definition is workable. Brazil's securities regulator sets a mechanical EBITDA (LAJIDA) calculation, starting from net profit, and requires any variant that strips out other items to be labelled "adjusted" (CVM Resolution 156 of 23 June 2022, articles 3 to 5).


What 2027 will look like instead

Shannonside Logistics plc, a fictional group, has operating profit of €42.0m after depreciation and amortisation of €31.0m, IAS 36 impairments of €5.0m and restructuring costs of €4.0m. Its €6.0m share of joint venture profit sits in the investing category. One set of accounts gives three figures that could be called EBITDA.


€m

Defined

With JVs

Adjusted

Operating profit

42.0

42.0

42.0

D&A

31.0

31.0

31.0

IAS 36 impairments

5.0

5.0

5.0

Share of JV profit

–

6.0

–

Restructuring costs

–

–

4.0

Subtotal

78.0

84.0

82.0


The first column, €42.0m + €31.0m + €5.0m = €78.0m, is the subtotal IFRS 18.118(b) exempts. The second adds €6.0m to reach €84.0m, the third adds back €4.0m to reach €82.0m, and both are management-defined performance measures with full disclosure. Nothing in IFRS 18 reserves the word. The second and third can be published as EBITDA or adjusted EBITDA, provided the label and description represent what each includes (IFRS 18.123, IFRS 18.B135). The irony is the first: because Shannonside has joint venture income in the investing category, the Board's own reasoning suggests the bare label would not describe the €78.0m subtotal accurately (BC365–BC366). The one defined figure is the one least safely called EBITDA. A reader comparing Shannonside with a peer must open the note to see which one is in front of them. Had the Board reserved the word for €78.0m, the other two would need other names.


What should happen now

The Board should reserve "EBITDA" for the subtotal in IFRS 18.118(b) and require anything else to carry a qualifier such as "adjusted". The post-implementation review is the natural moment, if it will not act sooner.


Until then, preparers can align a published EBITDA with the IFRS 18.118(b) calculation and take it out of the disclosure regime altogether, although an entity with investing-category income should give that subtotal a descriptive label rather than the bare acronym (BC365–BC366). Keeping a different calculation is legitimate, but it should be labelled as what it is. Auditors should treat the label as part of the measure: an "EBITDA" that is not the listed subtotal needs a description that makes the difference obvious (IFRS 18.B135).


The IASB did the hard part. It wrote down a calculation, exempted it and made the inputs disclosable (IFRS 18.83). Leaving the name unclaimed means one of the most quoted numbers in corporate reporting stays undefined in the one place it now has to appear.


Have your say

Do you agree that the Board should have claimed the label, or does an undefined EBITDA serve users better? Tell us.



Shannonside Logistics plc is fictional. References are to IFRS Accounting Standards as issued by the IASB.

bottom of page