Disclosure is not measurement
Updated: 3 days ago
When a company's sustainability statement says climate risk is material, and its financial statements show no climate effect on a single number, which of the two documents is wrong?

Open many of the large European annual reports for 2025 and you will find two accounts of the same company. The sustainability statement describes material climate risks, a transition plan with a carbon price path, physical risk to named sites and scenario analysis out to 2050. The financial statements carry the same plants, fleets and loan books at amounts that look as if none of it had been written. The notes may mention climate. The numbers usually do not.
The usual diagnosis is that the notes need more words. We disagree. The problem is rarely that the financial statements say too little about climate. It is that the numbers were never asked the question. That is a measurement failure, and the standards have required the answer for years.
The standards already ask
IFRS Accounting Standards barely mention climate, and do not need to. The measurements that matter already look forward.
A significant adverse change in the legal or market environment, such as a tighter emissions regime, is an indication of impairment (IAS 36.12(b)). Value in use must rest on reasonable and supportable assumptions, with greater weight on external evidence (IAS 36.33(a)). Carbon costs an asset will bear as it stands are not optional inputs.
Useful lives and residual values must be reviewed at least at each year-end (IAS 16.51), considering commercial obsolescence and legal limits on use (IAS 16.56(c), (d)). A plant that the transition plan says will close in 2032 cannot be depreciated to 2040.
A provision is the best estimate of the expenditure needed to settle a present obligation (IAS 37.36), including obligations to rectify environmental damage already done (IAS 37.19).
Expected credit losses must reflect reasonable and supportable information about forecasts of future economic conditions (IFRS 9.5.5.17(c)). A bank that runs climate scenarios for its supervisor and none for its loss allowance has chosen its audience.
Fair value uses the assumptions market participants would use (IFRS 13.22). If buyers price carbon, so must the valuer.
None of this is new. The IFRS Foundation's educational material, Effects of climate-related matters on financial statements, set it out standard by standard in November 2020 and republished it in July 2023 as a reminder of "long-standing requirements". ESMA, reviewing climate in financial statements in October 2023, considered IFRS "fit for purpose". The rules are not the gap.
What the IASB did, and did not, do
The IASB's own response confirms the diagnosis without curing it. Its project on climate-related and other uncertainties began because respondents to its agenda consultation said climate information in financial statements was insufficient or appeared inconsistent with what companies said elsewhere. The July 2024 exposure draft proposed eight illustrative examples; a near-final staff draft followed in July 2025; the final examples were issued on 28 November 2025. Every one of them is about disclosure: materiality judgements, assumptions, credit risk, decommissioning provisions, disaggregation. As the Board said in the exposure draft's basis, the examples "do not add or change requirements" (ED/2024/6, BC44).
That was the right call for a standard-setter that did not need new requirements. But the order of operations matters. In the exposure draft, the first example has a manufacturer explain that its transition plan has no effect on its numbers, and it earns that conclusion: the affected plants are nearly fully depreciated, recoverable amounts comfortably exceed carrying amounts, and there are no retirement obligations. The measurement came first; the sentence followed. Used the other way round, the same sentence becomes boilerplate. A note saying climate was considered and nothing changed is only as good as the impairment model behind it.
The case for caution
The strongest objection deserves a fair hearing. Climate effects are distant, uncertain and contested. IAS 36 tests the asset in its current condition and excludes cash flows from uncommitted restructurings and enhancements (IAS 36.44). IAS 37 does not provide for costs of operating differently in future (IAS 37.19), and the IFRS Interpretations Committee's April 2024 agenda decision on climate-related commitments confirmed that publishing a commitment to cut emissions does not, by itself, create a present obligation. IAS 37.43 warns that uncertainty does not justify excessive provisions. Put speculative climate numbers into the accounts, the argument runs, and you trade a reliable balance sheet for a fashionable one, built on management's views of policy in 2040.
All of that is correct, and none of it is an argument for leaving the numbers alone.
First, the limits bite on the good news, not the bad. IAS 36.44 keeps an uncommitted retrofit out of value in use, as we worked through in our IAS 36 post. It does not keep out the carbon bill the unretrofitted plant will pay. The prudent reading of the standards produces lower numbers for exposed assets, not unchanged ones.
Secondly, uncertainty is not zero. An impairment test that ignores a legislated carbon schedule has not avoided an estimate; it has made one, of nil, with no support. IAS 36.33(a) asks for management's best estimate of the range of economic conditions, not its most comfortable one. Where the range is wide, the answer is the sensitivity disclosure that IAS 1.125 (IAS 8.31A once IFRS 18 applies) already requires, not a silent assumption that today's conditions last for ever.
Thirdly, the numbers are not speculative when the company has already produced them. A transition plan with a dated closure, a carbon price used in capital allocation, a physical-risk map of flood-exposed sites: these are management's own assumptions, published and, for CSRD reporters, subject to limited assurance. Refusing to use them in the accounts, while asking investors to rely on them elsewhere in the same report, is the harder position to defend.
What connectivity demands
The sustainability standards have closed the escape route. IFRS S1 requires information that lets users understand the connections between sustainability disclosures and the financial statements (IFRS S1.21(b)(ii)), data and assumptions consistent with those statements as far as the accounting standards allow (IFRS S1.23), and disclosure of significant differences (IFRS S1.B42(c)). The ESRS say the same: consistency to the extent possible (ESRS 1.90 in the 2023 set; ESRS 1.116 in the simplified set, which also requires significant differences to be explained).
Regulators are reading both documents. In October 2022 IAASA said it was examining whether Irish issuers treated climate information consistently between the financial statements and their other publications, naming impairment, provisions and sensitivity analysis among the areas it had raised. ESMA's enforcement priorities for 2026, issued on 13 October 2026, record a mismatch in some cases between the risks in the sustainability statement and those elsewhere in the annual financial report, and note that some issuers omit the current financial effects of their material risks.
A simple test follows. For every climate risk the sustainability statement calls material, an investor should be able to point to the line in the financial statements it moved, or to the note explaining why it did not and what would make it. We suspect many 2025 reports would struggle with it. The 2026 reports need not.
Have your say
Carbon Copy: our sustainability section, including where climate reaches the financial statements.
The plan the impairment test ignores: what IAS 36 lets value in use count, and what it does not.
Suggest a question: disagree with this leader, or have a climate measurement question we should work through? Tell us.
Disclosure explains numbers; it does not replace them. A company that has done the work to say climate risk is material has done most of the work to measure it. The remaining step belongs in the accounts.





