A choice is not a judgement
Financial statements too often file accounting policy choices under "critical judgements". They are not judgements, and the habit weakens all three disclosures that IFRS keeps apart.

Most IFRS annual reports contain a note titled something like "critical accounting judgements and key sources of estimation uncertainty". It is also one regulators challenge most: the FRC says (July 2022) the topic has consistently featured among its corporate reporting reviewers' top ten matters of challenge. For years they have asked companies to make it specific, to quantify it and to stop repeating the standards.
Regulators have mostly policed one boundary, between judgements and estimates. A second matters as much: between the choices IFRS lets an entity make and the judgements it has to make. Preparers and auditors should stop blurring it, and 2027 is the year to stop.
Three things, three homes
IFRS distinguishes three things that judgements notes often run together.
A policy choice is a selection between options a standard permits. An entity "shall choose either the cost model … or the revaluation model" for each class of property, plant and equipment (IAS 16.29). It chooses the fair value model or the cost model for its investment property (IAS 40.30), FIFO or weighted average cost for similar inventories (IAS 2.25), and whether to present fair value changes on particular equity investments in other comprehensive income (IFRS 9.5.7.5). The facts do not decide these. Management does.
A judgement is a conclusion about how a policy applies to the facts, other than one involving estimation: whether risks and rewards have passed, whether a sale is in substance a financing, whether a financial asset's cash flows are solely payments of principal and interest (IAS 1.123). The facts drive the answer, and reasonable people can read them differently.
An estimate is a monetary amount subject to measurement uncertainty (IAS 8.5): an expected credit loss allowance, a net realisable value, a fair value, a depreciation charge, a warranty provision (IAS 8.32).
Each has its own disclosure. Policy choices belong in material accounting policy information, and IAS 1 gives as its example an entity that chose to measure investment property at cost rather than fair value (IAS 1.117B(b)). Judgements belong in the disclosure of those that have "the most significant effect on the amounts recognised" (IAS 1.122). Estimates belong in the disclosure of assumptions with a significant risk of a material adjustment within the next year, with the nature and carrying amount of the assets and liabilities affected (IAS 1.125). IAS 1 itself says the judgements and the estimation disclosures do not relate to each other (IAS 1.132).
Why the label matters
The label matters for three reasons.
First, each disclosure asks for different content. For a choice, the useful information is which option was taken, for which items, and why. IFRS sometimes says so expressly: an entity that designates equity investments at fair value through other comprehensive income must disclose which investments and "the reasons for using this presentation alternative" (IFRS 7.11A). For a judgement, the useful information is the facts, the competing answers and why one won. For an estimate, it is the assumptions, the carrying amount and the sensitivity. A choice filed as a judgement often gets a sentence saying the model was applied, with no reason for choosing it.
Second, a judgements label implies the facts compelled the answer. They did not. An entity reporting investment property at fair value could have used cost, and users comparing two property companies need to know that the difference between them is a decision, not a reading of different facts.
Third, the label can blur the accounting when things change. A voluntary change of policy is allowed only if it gives reliable and more relevant information (IAS 8.14(b)), is generally applied retrospectively (IAS 8.19(b), with exceptions such as a first move to revaluation under IAS 8.17) and must be explained, with reasons and the amounts affected (IAS 8.29). A change in estimate carries no such burden: it is recognised prospectively (IAS 8.36). If an elective policy has been described for years as a "judgement", it becomes easier to present a switch as a fresh judgement or a refined estimate rather than as a voluntary change of policy.
The record shows how weak the discipline is even on the boundary regulators do police. In its November 2017 thematic review, the FRC found that a third of the UK companies it reviewed did not clearly distinguish judgements from estimates, and a further 15% classified judgements involving estimation as judgements. Its July 2022 update still expected companies to "separately identify the judgements that do not relate to a source of estimation uncertainty and those that do". ESMA's enforcement priorities for 2024 annual reports, published on 24 October 2024, made accounting policies, judgements and significant estimates a priority, and told issuers to refrain from "merely repeating the IFRS requirements" (ESMA32-193237008-8369).
The case for not fussing
The strongest objection is that the categories overlap. Choosing a policy involves judgement: a voluntary change is allowed only if the new policy gives more relevant information (IAS 8.14(b)), and where no standard applies, management "shall use its judgement" to develop a policy (IAS 8.10). Some options are not entity-wide policies at all but instrument-by-instrument elections, such as the IFRS 9 equity election. The Board itself concedes that a change of policy and a change of estimate can be hard to tell apart, and tells entities to treat the change as one of estimate when in doubt (IAS 8.35). A strict taxonomy, on this view, only adds boxes and clutter.
We accept the overlap and reject the conclusion. Developing a policy where IFRS is silent is a judgement, and can properly sit in the judgements note alongside the policy information that IAS 1.117B(c) asks for. Choosing between options IFRS hands you is not, and no amount of thinking about relevance turns it into one. Instrument-by-instrument elections are still choices: IFRS 7.11A asks for the reasons, not for the facts that forced them. And IAS 8.35 is a rule for the rare hard case, not a licence to stop classifying. The Board is not shy about policing labels when it matters: IFRS 18 says in terms that an entity's selection of a management-defined performance measure "is not an accounting policy choice" (IFRS 18.124(c)).
Why 2027 is the moment
For annual periods beginning on or after 1 January 2027, IFRS 18 supersedes IAS 1 (IFRS 18.C1, C8), and these requirements move, almost word for word, into IAS 8, renamed Basis of Preparation of Financial Statements. Material accounting policy information becomes IAS 8.27A–27F, with policy choices at IAS 8.27C(b). Significant judgements become IAS 8.27G–27I. Sources of estimation uncertainty become IAS 8.31A–31I (IAS 8.54J). Every preparer will re-reference this note for 2027. The three requirements will sit side by side in one standard, which makes it harder to pretend they are one.
IFRS 18's transition adds a live example. On first application, an entity eligible to apply IAS 28.18 may change its election for an associate or joint venture from the equity method to fair value through profit or loss, and must apply that change retrospectively (IFRS 18.C7). That is a choice. Any entity that takes it should say so in its policy information, with its reasons, and keep it out of the judgements note.
The fix is simple. Preparers should split the note into what they chose, what they concluded and what they estimated, and file each under its own requirement. Auditors reviewing the draft should ask one question of every item in the judgements note: could the entity have answered differently on the same facts, simply by choosing to? If so, it is a choice, and it belongs with the policies.
Have your say
Is this a distinction worth fighting for, or a tidy-mindedness users will never notice? Tell us.
IAS 8 in the Learning Hub: accounting policies, estimates and errors, and the disclosures that move into IAS 8 from 2027.
RIP IAS 1 (1975–2026): our farewell to the standard these requirements are leaving.
Suggest a question for Unaddressed!
References are to IFRS Accounting Standards as issued by the IASB. IAS 1 references are to the standard as it applies until 31 December 2026; IAS 8 references to paragraphs 27A–27I and 31A–31I are to the amendments made by IFRS 18.





