Five thousand dollars, ten years on
IFRS 16 lets a lessee leave leases of low-value assets off its balance sheet, and its Basis for Conclusions says the Board had about US$5,000 in mind. Why was the exemption created, why that figure, and does the reasoning still hold a decade on?

Ask a finance team where the low-value lease line sits and most will answer with a number: US$5,000, or a local-currency version of it. Yet the number is not in IFRS 16. It appears in one sentence of the Basis for Conclusions (and again in the dissent that objects to it), framed as what the Board "had in mind" when it made its decisions in 2015.
That sentence has carried a lot of weight for ten years, while US consumer prices rose by more than 40%. Preparers used the IASB's post-implementation review of IFRS 16 to say the figure is outdated. The Board decided to do nothing. Was it right?
What the rule says
A lessee may elect not to apply the recognition and measurement requirements of IFRS 16 (paragraphs 22–49) to short-term leases and to leases for which the underlying asset is of low value (IFRS 16.5). The lease payments are then expensed on a straight-line or other systematic basis (IFRS 16.6). Unlike the short-term exemption, which is made by class of asset, the low-value election can be made lease by lease (IFRS 16.8).
The application guidance defines low value without a single number. Value is judged on the asset when new (IFRS 16.B3). The test is absolute, ignoring the size and circumstances of the lessee and applying whether or not the leases are material to it (IFRS 16.B4). The lessee must be able to benefit from the asset on its own or with other readily available resources, and the asset must not be highly dependent on, or highly interrelated with, other assets (IFRS 16.B5). Cars do not qualify (IFRS 16.B6), nor does a head lease of an asset that is subleased (IFRS 16.B7). Tablets, personal computers, small office furniture and telephones do (IFRS 16.B8). The lessee discloses that it uses the exemption and the related expense (IFRS 16.60, IFRS 16.53(d)).
What the Board said, and why
The exemption was a response to cost. Lessees told the Board that applying the new model to leases "large in number but low in value" would take significant effort for little effect on reported information (IFRS 16.BC84, BC98). The Board first considered addressing that through materiality, either by reminding preparers that immaterial leases are outside the requirements or by explaining how the materiality concept applies. It declined: materiality works for leases as it does for every other Standard, and no other Standard gives transaction-specific materiality guidance (IFRS 16.BC85–BC86).
Its fieldwork then found that, in most cases, the assets and liabilities from leases within the proposed exemption would not be material, even in aggregate (IFRS 16.BC101). That could have been an argument that the exemption was pointless. The Board read it the other way. Feedback from preparers persuaded it that the exemption would still give substantial relief, particularly to smaller entities, by removing the burden of justifying that such leases are immaterial in aggregate (IFRS 16.BC101).
The design follows from that purpose. Testing the asset rather than the lessee gives every lessee the same answer for the same asset (IFRS 16.BC100). The interdependence condition exists because the fieldwork suggested where aggregation was most likely to be material: large assets built from many cheap components, such as IT equipment (IFRS 16.BC102).
Then comes the sentence everyone remembers. At the time of reaching its decisions in 2015, the Board "had in mind" leases of assets with a value, when new, "in the order of magnitude of US$5,000 or less" (IFRS 16.BC100). Three features of that sentence matter. It is dated. It is an order of magnitude, not a limit. And it sits in the Basis, which accompanies the Standard but is not part of it.
Wei-Guo Zhang dissented from IFRS 16 partly because of this exemption. He thought materiality and the short-term exemption were enough, and that the exemption could encourage leasing over buying (IFRS 16.DO5–DO8). On the figure he was specific: the same asset costs different amounts in different markets, prices change and exchange rates move (IFRS 16.DO9).
The FASB went the other way. ASC 842 has no low-value exemption (IFRS 16.BC308); its Basis expects entities "will likely be able to adopt reasonable capitalization thresholds" instead (ASU 2016-02, BC122, as quoted by Deloitte). The IASB wrote an explicit exemption; the FASB left the job to materiality.
What has changed since
Two things: prices, and the evidence. On prices, the US Bureau of Labor Statistics' consumer price index for all urban consumers (CPI-U, 1982–84 = 100) averaged 237.017 in 2015. In September 2026, the latest month published, it stood at 336.940 (not seasonally adjusted).
CPI-U | Index | US$ |
|---|---|---|
2015 average | 237.017 | 5,000 |
Sep 2026 | 336.940 | 7,108 |
Increase | 42.2% | 2,108 |
The ratio is 336.940 ÷ 237.017 = 1.4216, so prices have risen by 42.2%. US$5,000 in 2015 money is US$5,000 × 1.4216 = US$7,108 at September 2026 prices, an increase of US$2,108. Put the other way, an unchanged US$5,000 line today admits only what US$3,517 bought in 2015. It compares a 2015 annual average with a single 2026 month, and US consumer prices rather than laptops in Dublin. It is an order of magnitude, which is all BC100 claimed.
On the evidence, the IASB's Request for Information on the post-implementation review of IFRS 16 was published on 17 June 2025, with comments due by 15 October 2025. The staff's January 2026 feedback summary reported that many who commented on the exemptions had not benefited from them as much as the Board expected. Their comments included that the US$5,000 reference and the car example were unclear, complicating materiality discussions with auditors, and that the figure had never been updated for inflation. Suggestions ranged from indexing it to deleting it. A few stakeholders, mostly standard-setters, worried about the opposite problem: contracts split into pieces that each fall below the line.
In March 2026 the staff recommended no action. The Basis is not authoritative, they said, so amending or deleting the figure would solve nothing. They also cited the IFRS Foundation's 2016 webcast with Board member Sue Lloyd, which, as the staff describe it, explained that US$5,000 should not be applied as a bright line without considering the current economic environment, inflation and other factors. On 24 March 2026 the Board tentatively agreed, with 11 of 13 members in favour. On 21 July 2026 it concluded that IFRS 16 is overall working as intended. A project summary and feedback statement is expected in the fourth quarter of 2026.
Does the reason still hold?
Take the reason and the number separately.
The reason holds. Leases of laptops, phones and office chairs are still numerous and cheap, the cost of proving their aggregate immateriality has not gone away, and the PIR shows preparers want more relief, not less. Mr Zhang's view that materiality alone would do the job looks weaker with hindsight. A few respondents said they must recognise immaterial leases simply because the asset does not qualify for the exemption. The staff replied that materiality might already keep such leases off the balance sheet. Perhaps, but preparers plainly take little comfort from materiality on its own. An explicit exemption gives them something an auditor can test.
The number does not hold, and it was not built to. A figure fixed in 2015 dollars has lost about 30% of its purchasing power (1 − 1 ÷ 1.4216). An entity that set its policy line at US$5,000 in 2018 and has not touched it since is applying a stricter exemption than the Board's 2015 order of magnitude implies today. Mr Zhang's warning about time and currency has turned out to be right.
We part company with the critics on the remedy. A number in the Standard would have been worse: it would now need amending, and the argument would be about the amount rather than the asset. The real fault is a dated figure left in the Basis for practice to treat as a rule. The staff are right that the Basis is not authoritative. Practice has made it so by habit.
What it means in practice
Read BC100 for what it says: an order of magnitude, as at 2015, in US dollars. An entity may set its policy at a level that reflects that order of magnitude today, provided it can explain how.
Write the threshold and its basis into the lease accounting policy: the BC100 reference, the index, the currency translation and the date of the last review. Review it periodically.
Keep applying B5 and B7 whatever the price. Interdependent components and subleased assets never qualify.
Do not stretch the exemption to cover leases that are merely immaterial. Use materiality for those, and say so.
Expect the auditor to test the policy line, the IFRS 16.53(d) expense, and whether contracts have been split to get under it.
The verdict
The exemption exists because the cost of accounting for cheap, numerous leases was out of proportion to the information it produced. That reason has survived ten years and a full post-implementation review. The US$5,000 has not, and was never meant to. The rule is that the asset must be of low value; the number only recorded what that meant in 2015. Apply it in today's prices, and make the policy say so.
Dig further
IFRS 16 in the Learning Hub: the lessee model, the recognition exemptions and the disclosures.
The two years nobody sublet: another IFRS 16 question from the Unaddressed! archive.
Suggest a question: a rule whose reasoning you would like us to dig into next.
References are to IFRS Accounting Standards as issued by the IASB. CPI-U data: US Bureau of Labor Statistics.





