The goodwill that cannot come back
IAS 36 requires most impairment losses to be reversed when the reasons for them reverse, but never a loss on goodwill. Why did the Board draw that line in 2004, and does its reasoning still hold?

Impairment under IAS 36 is normally a two-way street. If the estimates behind an asset's recoverable amount improve, the earlier loss is reversed, up to the carrying amount the asset would have had without it (IAS 36.114, IAS 36.117). Goodwill is the exception. Once written down, it stays down, however strongly the business recovers.
The rule has stood since 2004. Since its 2020 discussion paper the IASB has reopened the goodwill impairment test, and redeliberations are still running. Paragraph 124 has not been touched. Why did the Board ban reversals, and does the reason still stand?
What the rule says
An impairment loss recognised for goodwill shall not be reversed in a subsequent period (IAS 36.124). The next paragraph gives the reason in the Standard itself. IAS 38 prohibits recognising internally generated goodwill, and any later increase in the recoverable amount of goodwill is likely to be an increase in internally generated goodwill rather than a reversal of the loss on acquired goodwill (IAS 36.125, IAS 38.48).
The mechanics follow. When the impairment of a cash-generating unit reverses, the reversal is spread across the unit's other assets, but never to goodwill (IAS 36.122). And the ban extends to interim reporting: an entity shall not reverse an impairment loss on goodwill recognised in a previous interim period (IFRIC 10.8).
What the Board said, and why
The ban was not always there. IAS 22 required acquired goodwill to be amortised over its useful life, with a rebuttable presumption that the life did not exceed twenty years (IAS 36.BC131A). The 1998 version of IAS 36 required a goodwill impairment loss to be reversed, but only where the loss was caused by a specific external event of an exceptional nature, not expected to recur, and later events had reversed its effect (IAS 36.BC187).
The change came in the first phase of the business combinations project. The Board issued IFRS 3 and revised versions of IAS 36 and IAS 38 together in March 2004, replacing amortisation with an annual impairment test (IAS 36.BC2, BC131A). Its December 2002 exposure draft proposed prohibiting reversals, and most respondents agreed (IAS 36.BC187–BC188). Those who disagreed wanted goodwill treated like other assets, with reversals limited to losses caused by events beyond the entity's control (IAS 36.BC188).
The Board's reasoning is in one paragraph. Because IAS 38 prohibits recognising internally generated goodwill, a reversal would require the entity to show how much of a later increase in recoverable amount was a recovery of the acquired goodwill, rather than new goodwill built since. The Board concluded this "will seldom, if ever, be possible" (IAS 36.BC189). Acquired and internally generated goodwill contribute jointly to the same cash flows, so an increase in one cannot be told apart from an increase in the other. Even if the external event that caused the loss reverses, the recovery cannot be traced to the acquired goodwill (IAS 36.BC189).
The Board was candid about the weak point. Its own impairment test lets internally generated goodwill shield acquired goodwill from impairment, which some had called "backdoor" capitalisation (IAS 36.BC190). It accepted that inconsistency. It was less troubled by internally generated goodwill hiding a loss than by internally generated goodwill being recognised directly through a reversal (IAS 36.BC191). It had already concluded that no impairment test could remove the cushion that goodwill generated after an acquisition provides (IAS 36.BC135).
US GAAP got there first. SFAS 142, issued in June 2001, already required goodwill to be tested annually (IAS 36.BC216), and ASC 350 today prohibits reversing a goodwill impairment loss.
How IFRIC 10 hardened it
IAS 34 requires interim measurements to be made on a year-to-date basis, so that the frequency of reporting does not affect annual results (IAS 34.28, quoted in IFRIC 10.3). Read literally, that could mean a goodwill loss recognised at the half-year should be undone if, by the year-end, it would not have arisen (IFRIC 10.7). IFRIC 10, effective for annual periods beginning on or after 1 November 2006, said no: paragraph 124 wins (IFRIC 10.8). It also told entities not to extend that conclusion by analogy to other conflicts between IAS 34 and other Standards (IFRIC 10.9). IFRIC 10 still stands as a separate Interpretation in the 2026 edition of the Standards, and the annotated IAS 34 points to it.
The effect is easy to show. Kilbeggan Foods plc, which reports half-yearly, carries €12.0m of goodwill in a single cash-generating unit. At 30 June 2026 a sharp fall in forecasts produces a €3.0m impairment, all absorbed by goodwill. By 31 December the forecasts have recovered, and the unit's recoverable amount again exceeds a carrying amount that includes the full €12.0m. A twin entity that reports only annually, and tests goodwill each year at 31 December (IAS 36.96), would never have recognised a loss.
€m | Half-yearly | Annual only |
|---|---|---|
Goodwill 1 Jan 2026 | 12.0 | 12.0 |
Impairment 30 Jun | (3.0) | – |
Goodwill 31 Dec | 9.0 | 12.0 |
The half-yearly reporter ends the year with €12.0m − €3.0m = €9.0m of goodwill, permanently; the annual reporter keeps €12.0m. That is the sharpest cost of the rule.
What has changed since
The IASB's goodwill project has reopened almost everything around paragraph 124, but not paragraph 124 itself.
DP/2020/1 (March 2020). The Board's preliminary view was to keep the impairment-only model and not reintroduce amortisation, by eight votes of 14 (DP/2020/1, IN38).
November 2022. The Board confirmed that view on 24 November 2022, with ten of 11 members agreeing.
ED/2024/1 (March 2024, comments to 15 July 2024). It proposed disclosures about the performance of business combinations and targeted changes to IAS 36: clearer allocation of goodwill to reduce shielding, post-tax inputs for value in use, and allowing cash flows from uncommitted restructurings and asset enhancements (now excluded by IAS 36.44). The Board found "no compelling case" for amortisation (ED/2024/1, BC233), with many members stressing convergence with US GAAP (BC245). Neither document proposes changing the ban on reversals.
Redeliberations, 2025–2026. The Board tentatively confirmed post-tax inputs (July 2025) and the allocation changes (December 2025). On 21 April 2026 it kept the restructuring and enhancement proposal, nine of 13 members agreeing. It discussed performance disclosures on 23 September 2026 without decisions. As at October 2026 no amendments have been issued; transition and effective date are still to come.
Does the reason still hold?
The strongest case against the ban runs like this. Goodwill impairments are often driven by things outside the business: a rise in discount rates, a temporary collapse in a market. When those reverse, the write-down was simply wrong in hindsight, and keeping it overstates the loss. The Board has also already conceded that internally generated goodwill shields acquired goodwill on the way down (IAS 36.BC190). If that contamination is tolerable when it hides a loss, why not when it reveals a recovery? And IFRIC 10 shows the rule producing different numbers for the same business depending on how often it reports.
These are fair points; the first is what the 1998 standard tried to accommodate. But they do not answer BC189. The question is not whether the economics of the unit recovered. It is whether the recovery belongs to the goodwill that was bought or to goodwill built since, and nothing has made that easier to answer. If anything, the goodwill project makes it harder. Once value in use may include cash flows from restructurings and enhancements that management has not yet committed to, more of the recoverable amount will reflect future, internally generated value. Allowing reversals at the same time would let that value flow straight onto the balance sheet as goodwill.
The amortisation debate points the same way. Those who see goodwill as wasting argue that acquired goodwill is consumed and replaced by internally generated goodwill (IAS 36.BC131D(a); ED/2024/1, BC236), so any recovery is new goodwill by definition. Those who see it as long-lived end up at BC189: the two cannot be separated. Both camps support the ban. With US GAAP aligned and convergence weighing with the Board, there is little constituency for change.
The asymmetry the Board accepted in 2004 is real. It is still the right price. The shielding of acquired goodwill is a known limitation of a test on a cash-generating unit. Recognising internally generated goodwill through a reversal would do what IAS 38 forbids.
What it means in practice
Treat every goodwill impairment, including one at an interim date, as permanent. The half-year test deserves the same rigour as the year-end test.
When a unit's impairment reverses, allocate the reversal to the other assets of the unit, never to goodwill (IAS 36.122), and within the limits of IAS 36.123.
Watch headroom disclosures. Where a reasonably possible change in a key assumption would remove headroom, IAS 36.134(f) requires the sensitivity to be disclosed, and that is where readers see an irreversible loss coming.
The verdict
The Board banned reversals because a recovery in a unit's value cannot be traced to the goodwill that was bought rather than goodwill built since, and IAS 38 forbids recognising the latter. Twenty-two years, one Interpretation, a discussion paper and an exposure draft later, nobody has found a way to make that distinction. The reason holds. Write goodwill down with care, because it cannot come back.
Dig further
IAS 36 in the Learning Hub: recoverable amount, goodwill allocation and reversals.
The plan the impairment test ignores: the IAS 36.44 restriction the goodwill project would remove.
Unaddressed!: every question and column in the series.
Kilbeggan Foods plc is fictional. References are to IFRS Accounting Standards as issued by the IASB.





