Two rulebooks for sustainability reporting
Updated: 3 days ago
What do ESRS and IFRS S1 and S2 each require, how does double materiality differ from financial materiality, and who has to report under which set, and when, now that the EU's Omnibus changes have landed?

"Sustainability" covers a great deal, from personal habits to national policy. For companies and their auditors it now means something narrower and more demanding: a sustainability statement prepared under a recognised set of standards, published with the annual report and, in the EU, subject to assurance.
Two rulebooks dominate. The European Sustainability Reporting Standards (ESRS) apply to companies within the EU's Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD). IFRS S1 and IFRS S2, issued by the International Sustainability Standards Board (ISSB), are being adopted by jurisdictions elsewhere. This primer explains how they differ and where the EU position stands after a busy 2025 and 2026.
Why there are two sets
They answer different questions. IFRS S1 and S2 are written for investors and lenders: they require information about sustainability-related risks and opportunities that could reasonably be expected to affect the entity's prospects (IFRS S1.17). ESRS ask that question too, and a second one: what impact does the company have on people and the environment?
IFRS S1 sets the general requirements and covers all sustainability-related risks and opportunities; IFRS S2 deals with climate. Both are effective, as issued by the ISSB, for annual periods beginning on or after 1 January 2024, but each jurisdiction that adopts them sets its own date, and an entity may report on climate only in its first year (IFRS S1.E5). ESRS consist of two cross-cutting standards (ESRS 1 and ESRS 2) and ten topical standards: five environmental (E1 to E5), four social (S1 to S4) and one on business conduct (G1).
Feature | ESRS | ISSB |
|---|---|---|
Materiality | Double | Financial |
Main users | Investors and others | Investors, lenders |
Climate | ESRS E1 | IFRS S2 |
Legal force | EU law | Where adopted |
Assurance | Limited (CSRD) | Set locally |
Double and financial materiality
Financial materiality is the familiar test. Under IFRS S1, information is material if omitting, misstating or obscuring it could reasonably be expected to influence decisions that primary users make on the basis of general purpose financial reports (IFRS S1.18).
ESRS keep that test and add a second. Double materiality has two dimensions, impact materiality and financial materiality, and the undertaking must consider how they interact (ESRS 1, paragraph 35, 2026 set). A topic is material from an impact perspective if it relates to material actual or potential, positive or negative impacts on people or the environment, including through the value chain and the company's products and services (ESRS 1, paragraph 39). It is material from a financial perspective if it triggers, or could reasonably be expected to trigger, material financial effects on the undertaking (ESRS 1, paragraph 47). A topic meets the double materiality criterion if it is material from either perspective or both (ESRS defined terms, 2026 set).
Consider Tullyvarra Creamery Ltd, a fictional Irish dairy processor. Its effluent affects a local river: an impact on the environment. Regulators have not yet acted and the cost of upgrades is small, so the impact may not be financially material. Under ESRS it is reported because the impact is material. Under IFRS S1 it would be reported only if it could reasonably be expected to affect Tullyvarra's prospects. By contrast, the risk that drought interrupts its milk supply is a financial risk that both sets would capture.
Who reports what, and when, in the EU
The original CSRD timetable has been rewritten twice. The Stop-the-clock Directive (EU) 2025/794 postponed the later waves by two years. The Omnibus I Directive (EU) 2026/470, in force since 18 March 2026, then narrowed the scope to undertakings and groups with more than 1,000 employees on average and net turnover above €450m. Member States must transpose it by 19 March 2027; Ireland, which implemented the CSRD through S.I. No. 336 of 2024, had not yet done so at the time of writing.
Who | Financial years |
|---|---|
Wave 1, in new scope | 2024 onwards |
Wave 1, outside scope | 2024 to 2026 |
Others in new scope | 2027 onwards |
Listed SMEs | – |
Non-EU groups | 2028 onwards |
Wave 1 companies that fall outside the new thresholds report only for financial years 2024 to 2026, and Member States may exempt them for 2025 and 2026 (Directive (EU) 2022/2464, Article 5(2), as amended). Non-EU groups come in from 2028 if they generate more than €450m of net turnover in the EU.
The standards themselves have also changed. The Commission adopted simplified ESRS on 3 July 2026 as Delegated Regulation (EU) 2026/1563, published on 21 September 2026 and in force from 10 November 2026. They apply to financial years beginning on or after 1 January 2027. For 2026, companies may stay on the 2023 set, adopt the 2026 set early, or use the 2023 set with listed reliefs, and must say which they chose. Paragraph numbers differ between the two sets. EU Taxonomy reporting continues for companies in scope, simplified by a delegated act that has applied since 1 January 2026.
Where the ISSB Standards apply
The ISSB Standards have legal force only where a jurisdiction adopts them. At the end of March 2026 the IFRS Foundation counted more than 40 jurisdictions that had decided to use the ISSB Standards or were taking steps to introduce them. Its list of effective dates included 2025 for Australia, Hong Kong SAR, Malaysia, Pakistan and Singapore, and 2026 for Brazil, Chile and the Philippines, with the United Kingdom, Japan and Canada among those still to be determined.
For a group reporting in both worlds, the IFRS Foundation and EFRAG published interoperability guidance on 2 May 2024 explaining how a company applying the 2023 ESRS can also meet the ISSB Standards, particularly on climate.
What the auditor will look at
Which framework and version. The basis of preparation, including which ESRS set applies for 2026 and any transitional reliefs used.
The materiality assessment. How impacts, risks and opportunities were identified, the thresholds applied, and whether the conclusions are supported. Under ESRS this is the gate to everything else.
Connectivity with the accounts. Whether amounts and assumptions in the sustainability statement agree with the financial statements (IFRS S1.21).
Assurance basis. CSRD assurance is limited assurance; the Omnibus removed the planned move to reasonable assurance and set 1 July 2027 for EU limited assurance standards. ISSA 5000, as issued by the IAASB, is effective for periods beginning on or after 15 December 2026; in Ireland, ISAE (Ireland) 3000 applies to CSRD assurance until IAASA adopts a replacement.
Work it through with our tools
A sustainability statement is only as good as the financial statements it connects to. Our free Disclosure Review checklist covers the IFRS disclosures most often linked to climate, including estimation uncertainty and impairment assumptions.
IAS 36 in the Learning Hub: where climate assumptions meet the impairment test.
IAS 8 in the Learning Hub: judgements and estimation uncertainty under the new basis of preparation.
More Carbon Copy posts: ESRS, IFRS S1 and IFRS S2 read the way an auditor reads them.
Sustainability reporting has moved from aspiration to regulation, and the regulation itself is still settling. The core is stable, though: decide which rulebook applies, apply its materiality test honestly, and make sure the sustainability statement and the financial statements describe the same company.
Tullyvarra Creamery Ltd is fictional. ESRS references are to the 2026 set in Delegated Regulation (EU) 2026/1563 unless stated.





