When nature becomes material
Updated: 3 days ago
Human pressure on the climate, air, water, land and species is well documented. When does that pressure become something a company must report under ESRS E1 to E5, and who decides?

The scientific record is not in dispute. The IPCC's Sixth Assessment Report found that human activities, principally through greenhouse gas emissions, have unequivocally caused global warming, with global surface temperature 1.1°C above 1850–1900 in 2011–2020 (IPCC AR6 Synthesis Report, 2023). Copernicus measured 2024 at 1.60°C above pre-industrial levels and 2025 at 1.47°C (Copernicus, January 2026). For nature, IPBES found in 2019 that 75% of the land surface is significantly altered, 66% of the ocean area is experiencing increasing cumulative impacts, over 85% of wetland area has been lost and around 1 million species already face extinction (IPBES Global Assessment, 2019).
None of that, on its own, puts a line in a sustainability statement. Under the European Sustainability Reporting Standards, a topic is reported because the undertaking's double materiality assessment says it is.
From pressure to standard
ESRS has five environmental standards, each covering a group of these pressures.
ESRS E1 Climate Change: greenhouse gas emissions, energy, and physical and transition climate risks.
ESRS E2 Pollution: emissions to air, water and soil, and substances of concern.
ESRS E3 Water (Water and Marine Resources in the 2023 set): water withdrawal, consumption and discharge.
ESRS E4 Biodiversity and Ecosystems: land use, ecosystem condition and species.
ESRS E5 Resource Use and Circular Economy: resource inflows, outflows and waste.
Two sets of ESRS now exist. The 2023 set (Delegated Regulation (EU) 2023/2772) applies until the simplified 2026 set (Delegated Regulation (EU) 2026/1563) takes over for financial years beginning on or after 1 January 2027. For 2026 years, companies may stay on the 2023 set, adopt the new set early, or use the 2023 set with listed reliefs, including the new top-down approach to materiality (Delegated Regulation (EU) 2026/1563, Article 2). Paragraph numbers differ between the sets, so each reference below names its set.
What double materiality asks
Double materiality has two dimensions (ESRS 1.37, 2023 set; ESRS 1.35, 2026 set).
Impact materiality. A topic is material if it relates to the undertaking's material actual or potential, positive or negative impacts on people or the environment, including through its value chain (ESRS 1.43, 2023 set; ESRS 1.39, 2026 set). Negative impacts are judged on severity, meaning scale, scope and irremediable character, and, for potential impacts, likelihood (ESRS 1.40, 2026 set).
Financial materiality. A topic is material if it generates risks or opportunities that could reasonably be expected to affect the undertaking's financial position, performance, cash flows, access to finance or cost of capital (ESRS 1.49, 2023 set; ESRS 1.47, 2026 set).
A topic is reported if it passes either test. The starting point is usually impacts, but risks unrelated to the undertaking's own impacts, such as physical climate risk, must also be assessed (ESRS 1.36, 2026 set). That is the main difference from IFRS S1, where materiality is judged only by its effect on the decisions of primary users of general purpose financial reports (IFRS S1.18).
What the 2026 set changed
The 2026 set keeps both dimensions but lightens the assessment.
A top-down approach: the undertaking may conclude on a topic from an analysis of its strategy, business model, sectors, geographies and value chain, and assess individual impacts only where the answer is not evident (ESRS 1.27, 2026 set).
No exhaustive search: reasonable and supportable information available without undue cost or effort, focused on areas where material matters are likely (ESRS 1.32 and AR 13(b), 2026 set). Quantitative scoring is not necessarily required (ESRS 1 AR 13(a), 2026 set).
Less noise: information that is not material is not to be disclosed (ESRS 1.24, 2026 set).
A periodic review: at each reporting date, the undertaking considers whether significant changes require the assessment to be updated (ESRS 1.34, 2026 set).
The population doing this has also shrunk. Omnibus I, Directive (EU) 2026/470, limits CSRD reporting to undertakings with more than 1,000 employees and more than €450m net turnover. Member States must transpose it by 19 March 2027; Ireland has not yet done so.
Worked example: Ardvarna Packaging plc
Ardvarna Packaging plc makes corrugated packaging in Galway and two other EU sites. It has 1,400 employees, €610m of net turnover and EBITDA of €60.0m, and a 31 December year-end. Its boilers burn natural gas, its main mill discharges treated process water to a river, and it buys recovered fibre.
Ardvarna documents its own method; ESRS does not prescribe one. Severity is the average of scale, scope and irremediable character, each scored 1 to 5, and a potential impact is weighted by likelihood. An impact is material at 3.0 or above. A risk is financially material if the plausible effect on EBITDA is at least 2%, which is 2% × €60.0m = €1.2m.
Topic | Severity | Exposure €m | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
E1 Climate | 3.7 | 1.8 | Both |
E2 Pollution | 3.0 | 0.3 | Impact only |
E3 Water | 1.7 | 0.2 | Neither |
E4 Biodiversity | 2.0 | – | Neither |
E5 Circularity | 3.3 | 2.6 | Both |
The arithmetic behind the severity column:
E1: boiler and fleet emissions scored 3, 4 and 4, so (3 + 4 + 4) ÷ 3 = 3.7. Carbon costs under the EU Emissions Trading System (its mill is an EU ETS installation) give an exposure of €1.8m, above €1.2m.
E2: the river discharge scored 4, 3 and 2, so (4 + 3 + 2) ÷ 3 = 3.0, exactly at the threshold. The plausible cost of permit breaches is €0.3m.
E3: abstraction in a dry summer is a potential impact scored 3, 3 and 4, a severity of 3.3, weighted by a likelihood of 0.5 to give 1.7.
E4: land-use effects of fibre sourcing scored 2, 2 and 2, so 2.0.
E5: dependence on recovered fibre and packaging waste scored 3, 3 and 4, so 3.3. A rise in recovered fibre prices is a €2.6m exposure.
The key result is E2. Pollution is material because of what Ardvarna does to the river, even though the financial exposure is a quarter of the threshold. A financial-materiality-only assessment would miss it. Ardvarna reports E1, E2 and E5, and says why E3 and E4 are not material.
Under the top-down approach, Ardvarna could have concluded on E4 without scoring it (ESRS 1.27, 2026 set). And because non-material information is not to be disclosed, it should not add water metrics for comfort (ESRS 1.24, 2026 set).
Why it matters for the next year-end
A company that stays on the 2023 set for 2026 still moves to the 2026 set for 2027, and will revisit its assessment when it does. The top-down approach can cut work, but only if the strategy analysis behind it is written down. A conclusion of "not material" is now a positive choice that removes disclosures, and an assurance provider will ask for the evidence.
What the auditor will look at
The method: scoring scales, thresholds and how severity and likelihood combine, applied consistently across topics.
The evidence for impacts: engagement with affected stakeholders, which the 2026 set treats as a key input (ESRS 1.42, 2026 set), site data and permits.
The link to the financial statements: whether risks judged material are reflected in impairment, provisions and estimates, and the reverse.
Top-down conclusions: whether the strategy and value chain analysis supports each one.
Periodic review: what changed since last year, and whether the assessment was updated (ESRS 1.34, 2026 set).
The assurance basis: ISSA 5000 is effective for periods beginning on or after 15 December 2026 where adopted, and the Commission's own limited assurance standards are now due by 1 July 2027.
Work it through with our tools
A financially material environmental risk often lands in the financial statements first.
IAS 37 in the Learning Hub: environmental provisions, restoration obligations and contingent liabilities.
IAS 36 in the Learning Hub: when climate or resource risk becomes an impairment indicator.
Where a materiality call is close, The Tipping Point helps you weigh the indicators and record the judgement.
More Carbon Copy posts are on the Unaddressed! series page.
The science describes what humanity is doing to the planet. Double materiality decides which part of that story an individual company has to tell: what it does to the environment, what the environment can do to it, or both. The 2026 set makes the test leaner, not looser, and a company that cannot show its reasoning has not done it.
First published in August 2023 and rewritten in October 2026. Ardvarna Packaging plc is fictional, and its scoring method is illustrative; ESRS does not prescribe one.





